A Kalshi-branded exchange kiosk with its shutter half closed as a large judge's gavel hovers above it, ready to force it shut.

Kalshi Warns New York Order Could Shut Exchange Nationwide

Kalshi's lawyers asked Manhattan Justice Melissa Crane for a status conference after a federal judge remanded New York's $36 billion suit, warning a renewed restraining order could shut the exchange nationwide and clash with a CFTC emergency order.

Hadi GhadbanNovember 20, 20263 min read
Share

Kalshi's lawyers at Milbank have told a Manhattan judge that a restraining order New York Attorney General Letitia James may now renew could force the prediction market to stop serving customers across the U.S. According to sports and gaming attorney Daniel Wallach, who described the filing on Nov. 20, Milbank sent a late-night letter to Justice Melissa Crane of Manhattan Supreme Court. The letter asks for an immediate status conference and a chance to respond to any renewed application from James.

Why the letter was sent

The filing followed a Nov. 19 ruling by U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick, who granted New York's request to send its enforcement lawsuit back to state court because the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction. Broderick denied the state's request for attorneys' fees and costs, finding Kalshi had reasonable grounds to seek removal.

James filed the $36 billion suit on July 31, and Kalshi moved it to federal court the same day. Her original restraining order application was denied as moot, and Wallach said she can renew it now that the case is back in state court. Kalshi argues she has not shown an emergency that would justify an ex parte order, meaning one imposing restrictions before Kalshi presents a defense.

The nationwide reach

The requested restrictions cover contracts on "sports, culture, elections, and other events" offered "within or from New York or to persons in New York." Because Kalshi is headquartered in New York, Milbank reportedly argued the language could bar it from serving customers elsewhere. It also questioned whether the undefined "other events" could sweep in contracts on financial markets and economic indicators.

Milbank cited figures from the attorney general's own filings: $178 billion in annualized trading volume and a $22 billion valuation. An order, it warned, could force liquidation of open positions and disrupt markets in jurisdictions where the contracts are permitted.

Federal preemption arguments

Kalshi leaned on the CFTC's Aug. 11 emergency order under Section 8a(9) of the Commodity Exchange Act, which directed it to keep operating its exchange under federal requirements. The CFTC called New York's action a "major market disturbance" and a shutdown an "existential threat." Milbank argues a restraining order would create conflicting state and federal directives.

Kalshi also reportedly cited the Third Circuit's decision in KalshiEX v. Flaherty, which found federal commodities law preempted the New Jersey gambling restrictions at issue. New Jersey has sought Supreme Court review.

New York's position

The state says Kalshi runs an unlicensed gambling business and that federal registration does not exempt it from New York licensing, taxation and consumer protection rules. It also raised access by 18-to-20-year-olds, given the state's minimum mobile sports betting age of 21. The suit seeks financial penalties, consumer restitution and forfeiture of profits.

Wallach noted that the State Gaming Commission issued a cease-and-desist notice on Oct. 24, 2025, before deferring enforcement, which cuts against Kalshi's suggestion that New York waited months before acting. In his chronology, Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi's request on July 7, 2026, and Kalshi lost an emergency injunction bid on July 27 while appealing.

Kalshi contacted the attorney general's office Thursday evening about scheduling, Wallach said, and the state replied that it would respond the next day. Kalshi filed before getting that answer.

What it means

The fight is one front in a broader state-federal conflict. The Justice Department and CFTC recently sued Arkansas to block its enforcement case against Kalshi. In New York, the question is now whether one state court can issue an order with national consequences for a federally registered exchange.

Discussion

Loading comments...