Germany: German Judge Offers to Drop Movie2k Case for 40,000 Bitcoin
Photo: Ansgar Koreng / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 de

German Judge Offers to Drop Movie2k Case for 40,000 Bitcoin

A Leipzig Regional Court judge offered to drop the Movie2k piracy case if the alleged operator surrenders 40,000 BTC and pays €38 million to potential victims. He could still keep about 16,000 BTC. The trial resumes Dec. 3.

Blockchain Academics NewsroomNovember 19, 20262 min read
Share

A judge at the Leipzig Regional Court has offered to dismiss the criminal case against the alleged operator of the defunct Movie2k piracy site if he hands over 40,000 bitcoin, a stake worth about $2.56 billion at current prices. The defendant would also pay compensation to potential victims.

Presiding judge Karsten Nickel made the offer last week, according to reports published Nov. 18, in a trial that began in February. A spokesman for the Dresden prosecutors' office confirmed the proposal. The Leipzig court had not issued its own confirmation at that time. Public broadcaster MDR reported from the court on the proposal.

Terms of the proposal

The compensation component is €38 million, about $41.6 million. The proposal also requires the defendant to give up any claim to roughly €2.64 billion that Saxony raised by selling earlier-seized bitcoin, the newspaper Freie Presse reported. Those proceeds sit with the state justice treasury and still belong to him until a final confiscation ruling.

About 49,858 BTC was transferred on Jan. 16, 2024, and sold between June 19 and July 12, 2024, for €2,639,683,413.92.

Prosecutors believe the defendant still holds about 56,000 BTC. Handing over 40,000 would leave roughly 16,000 BTC, about $1.02 billion at around $64,000 per coin.

Even after a deal, he could leave court a billionaire.

Co-defendant and next steps

A co-defendant, a Polish national charged with money laundering in 46 cases and especially serious tax evasion, was offered terms of 600 BTC plus €17 million. His lawyer said she could imagine accepting.

The main defendant's lawyers said they wanted to confer. Prosecutors and defense are reviewing the proposal, and no decision has been announced. The trial resumes Dec. 3 and could end before Christmas if both sides agree.

The main defendant faces charges of commercial money laundering in 146 cases. The court has ruled about 220,000 copyright counts time-barred.

Background

Movie2k.to ran from 2008 until it was shut down in May 2013. Prosecutors say the operators used advertising revenue to buy bitcoin. Two other men were convicted in 2023 and received suspended sentences.

In April, Nickel floated a suspended sentence if the defendant confessed and gave investigators access to another 57,000 BTC. He has since questioned whether all the coins came from illegal activity, saying proof of some charges would face "great difficulties" and that legally and illegally obtained bitcoin may have been mixed in the accounts.

If accepted, the deal would end a full trial in exchange for coins worth more than $2.5 billion, making a bitcoin position the central settlement variable in a criminal proceeding.

Discussion

Loading comments...