Supreme Court of the United States: Supreme Court Denies Custodia Appeal on Fed Master Account
Photo: UpstateNYer / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Supreme Court Denies Custodia Appeal on Fed Master Account

The U.S. Supreme Court on Nov. 16 denied certiorari in Custodia Bank's master account case, leaving Reserve Banks free to turn away legally eligible applicants. Limited accounts like Kraken's and the Fed's proposed payment account remain narrower routes.

Hadi GhadbanNovember 16, 20263 min read
Share

Regional Federal Reserve Banks remain free to turn away legally eligible applicants for master accounts after the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday, Nov. 16, declined to hear Custodia Bank's challenge to its rejection. The Court denied certiorari in Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, No. 26-62, according to its order list. It gave no explanation, and the denial is not a ruling on the merits.

A master account gives a bank direct access to Federal Reserve payment rails. Without one, an institution must route payments through intermediary banks.

What the denial leaves in place

The decision cements the Tenth Circuit's Oct. 31, 2025 opinion, which held that Reserve Banks have discretion over master accounts. The panel split 2-1. Judge Ebel, joined by Judge Rossman, found that Section 342's "may receive" language is discretionary, and that the Monetary Control Act's "shall be available" wording is a pricing rule, not an access mandate.

Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented, writing:

"We are bound by the ordinary language of the statute and, in my view, shall means shall,"

Judge Timothy Tymkovich

Tymkovich also warned of a result "akin to a death sentence." The full Tenth Circuit denied rehearing on March 13, 2026, with Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid voting to grant it.

Procedural history

Custodia, a Wyoming-chartered digital-asset bank, applied to the Kansas City Fed in October 2020. In January 2021, the Kansas City Fed confirmed the bank's legal eligibility and said there were "no showstoppers." Custodia sued over the delay in June 2022.

The Kansas City Fed denied the application on Jan. 27, 2023, citing risks of the bank's crypto-focused business model. The Board denied Custodia's separate August 2021 application for Fed membership the same day. District Judge Scott Skavdahl ruled for the Kansas City Fed on March 29, 2024.

Custodia, represented by Kannon Shanmugam, filed its petition in July 2026. The Kansas City Fed filed its opposition on Oct. 13, arguing that eligibility cannot confer an absolute entitlement regardless of risks to the payment system. Custodia replied on Oct. 28, contending the ruling undermines states' authority to charter banks and that correspondent banking is costlier and adds counterparty credit risk. The Court distributed the case for its Nov. 13 conference.

Neither Custodia nor its chief executive, Caitlin Long, had commented as of Monday morning.

Narrower routes remain

The outcome is not a blanket ban. Kraken Financial, also a Wyoming special purpose depository institution, received a limited-purpose account from the Kansas City Fed in March 2026. It is Fedwire-only and runs one year, with no intraday credit or discount-window access, a cap on closing balances and no interest.

The Fed Board separately proposed a restricted payment account in May and asked Reserve Banks to pause Tier 3 access decisions. The Board expected that pause to end on or before Dec. 31, 2026. The proposal does not guarantee approval for Custodia or anyone else.

What it means for market participants

The practical message is that a state charter does not guarantee Fed access. Crypto-focused banks seeking direct payment connectivity depend on Reserve Bank discretion, and a limited-purpose account like Kraken's is the one route granted so far. Others will keep relying on correspondent banks or private payment services, with the cost and counterparty exposure Custodia described in its briefing.

Critics have called the broader pattern of crypto firms being shut out of banking "Operation Choke Point 2.0." With the courts closed to Custodia, the Board's restricted-account rulemaking is the narrower path still open.

Discussion

Loading comments...