Skip to content
Ripple vs SEC

Ripple’s Legal Battle With the SEC Intensifies Amidst Resilient XRP Performance

The legal conflict between Ripple Labs and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) continues to escalate, as the SEC recently filed an appeal against a pivotal court decision from July 2023. The ruling, delivered by Judge Analisa Torres, distinguished between different types of XRP transactions, declaring that sales on exchanges did not qualify as securities, while institutional sales did.

This partial victory for Ripple was accompanied by an order to pay a $125 million civil penalty for its institutional XRP sales. Yet, the SEC remains determined to challenge the court’s interpretation of secondary market transactions, reigniting tensions in a case that has captured the cryptocurrency industry’s attention.

Central to the SEC’s argument is the application of the Howey Test, a legal framework used to determine whether a transaction qualifies as an investment contract. According to the SEC, Ripple’s promotional activities fostered expectations of profit among investors, satisfying one of the key elements of the test. The agency further contends that the “investment of money” criterion is met by Ripple’s distribution of XRP in non-cash transactions, such as employee compensation and business incentives.

This legal maneuver comes at a significant moment for the SEC, as changes in its leadership are anticipated. Despite this, the agency has remained steadfast in its pursuit of Ripple. Stuart Alderoty, Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer, voiced his frustration with the SEC’s actions, calling them a “waste of taxpayer money.” He noted, “On January 20, Gensler’s war on crypto ends at the SEC. We asked the SEC to agree to postpone the filing of their opening brief in their appeal of our victory—current deadline January 15—and they refused. What a waste of time and taxpayer dollars.”

Ripple’s criticism reflects broader concerns within the cryptocurrency sector regarding the SEC’s approach to regulation under Gary Gensler’s leadership. However, this dynamic may soon shift. Key Republican officials within the SEC, including Commissioners Hester Peirce and Mark Uyeda, are reportedly exploring ways to establish clearer guidelines for classifying cryptocurrencies as securities. Sources suggest that under President Donald Trump’s administration, Paul Atkins is poised to take over as SEC Chair, potentially marking a turning point for the agency’s regulatory stance.

While optimism surrounds the possibility of a more crypto-friendly SEC leadership, these changes depend on Atkins’ confirmation by the Senate. In the meantime, the ongoing legal dispute remains a focal point for both Ripple and the broader crypto market.

Interestingly, despite the intensifying legal pressure, XRP’s market performance has demonstrated remarkable resilience. The token recently surged by 9.21%, reaching $3.08, according to CoinMarketCap. This price increase occurred even as the SEC filed a “Civil Appeal Pre-Argument Statement” on October 17, signaling its intent to continue challenging Ripple.

While XRP has experienced minor fluctuations amid these developments, overall market sentiment remains optimistic. Ripple’s ability to maintain investor confidence amidst regulatory scrutiny highlights the broader implications of this legal battle for the future of cryptocurrency regulation.

Related Blog